Shin kafafen yaɗa labarai na Yammacin Duniya sun juya wa Isra'ila baya ne a ƙarshe?
DUNIYA
5 minti karatu
Shin kafafen yaɗa labarai na Yammacin Duniya sun juya wa Isra'ila baya ne a ƙarshe?Daga BBC zuwa The Atlantic, kafafen yaɗa labarai da dama sun yi tur da tsarin Isra'ila a kan Gaza a wani haɗin-kai da ba a saba gani ba na ƙin goyon bayan Amurka a tallafa wa Tel Aviv a yaƙin kisan ƙare-dangin da take yi.
Major Western media outlets only recently began questioning Israel’s immorality during the war and started to pull back their longstanding support for Israeli military actions. / AP
19 Mayu 2025

Shekaru da dama, kafafen yada labarai na Ƙasashen Yamma sun kasance suna ba da labarai masu kama da juna game da Isra'ila, inda suka fi mayar da hankali kan damuwar tsaron Isra'ila da hakkinta na kare kanta, yayin da suka yi watsi da wahalhalun da Falasdinawa ke fuskanta a gefe.

Duk da rahotanni da ke ƙiyasta mutuwar fararen hula Falasdinawa tsakanin 77,000 zuwa 109,000 tun bayan fara yaƙin sojan Isra'ila a ranar 7 ga Oktoba, sai a kwanan nan ne wadannan kafafen yada labarai suka fara dasa ayar tambaya kan rashin adalcin Isra'ila a yaƙin da take yi, tare da fara janye goyon bayansu na dogon lokaci ga ayyukan sojan Isra'ila.

Tun makon da ya gabata, jaridu kamar Financial Times da The Economist sun wallafa rubuce-rubuce masu tsanani kan shirin yaƙin Firaminista Benjamin Netanyahu da kuma rashin saurin shiga tsakani daga Washington.

Thomas Friedman, marubucin ra'ayi a The New York Times, wanda ya daɗe yana goyon bayan Isra'ila, yanzu yana gargadi cewa “wannan gwamnatin Isra'ila ba abokiyar ƙawancenmu ba ce” kuma yana zarginta da lalata muradun Amurka a yankin.

A cikin wannan makon, Financial Times ta yi Allah wadai da “shiru na abin kunya na Ƙasashen Yamma kan Gaza” yayin da The Atlantic ta danganta alkawarin Netanyahu na “samun tabbatacciyar nasara” da manufar “kawar da Falasdinawa.”

The Economist ta bayyana cewa “dole ne yaƙin ya ƙare” kuma ta buƙaci Shugaba Donald Trump ya tilasta “tsagaita wuta.”

Me ya sa wannan sauyin ra'ayi mai tsanani daga manyan kafafen yada labarai ya faru kwatsam? Shin hakan yana nuna wani sauyi mai muhimmanci a tattaunawar ƙasa da ƙasa game da Isra'ila?

“Netanyahu ba abokinmu ba ne”

Sauyin da ake gani a kafafen yada labarai na Ƙasashen Yamma game da Isra'ila ba ya bayyana a matsayin wani abu na bazata.

Akwai rubuce-rubuce da ke nuna abubuwa da dama ciki har da saɓani tsakanin Fadar White House da Netanyahu kan dabarun Gaza da Iran, da kuma karin hujjoji cewa harin Isra'ila ya tsaya cak a fagen yaƙi kuma yana haifar da koma baya a siyasa, inda sama da kashi 60 cikin 100 na Isra'ilawa ke adawa da sabon farmakin kasa da kuma yadda kira ga sojojin ko-ta-kwana da su ajiye makamai ba ya samun karbuwa.

Yayin da mutuwar fararen hula ke karuwa, rubuce-rubuce sun yi gargadin cewa mamayar Gaza da Isra'ila ke yi na ci gaba na zama “kisan kare dangi.”

A cewar wani bincike da BBC ta ambata, kashi 46 cikin 100 na Amurkawa ne kawai yanzu ke nuna goyon baya ga Isra'ila — mafi karanci cikin shekaru 25 — yayin da goyon bayan Falasdinawa ya kai wani matsayi na tarihi na kashi 33 cikin 100.

Sauyin ra'ayin kafafen yada labarai ya kuma dace da karuwar rashin jituwa tsakanin Netanyahu da gwamnatin Trump, kamar yadda aka bayyana a cikin wani labari na Shalom Lipner a mujallar Foreign Policy game da yiwuwar “takaddama” tsakanin Netanyahu da Trump.

Labarin ya mayar da hankali kan yadda Firaministan Isra'ila ke “gano cewa damar da yake da ita na yin dabaru a wannan fagen siyasa ta ragu sosai” a Washington, inda goyon bayan 'yan jam'iyyar Republican yanzu “ke karkashin tasirin Trump.”

Wannan batu ya ƙara fitowa fili yayin da Shugaban Amurka ya kauce wa ziyartar Isra'ila a rangadin Gabas ta Tsakiya saboda “ba abin da zai samu daga ziyartar Isra'ila a wannan lokacin.”

Rubutun Friedman a NYT, a wannan rana, ya yi magana kai tsaye kan Shugaba Trump, yana cewa, “wannan gwamnatin Isra'ila tana yin abubuwan da ke barazana ga muradun Amurka a yankin. Netanyahu ba abokinmu ba ne.”

Ya yi ikirarin cewa fifikon gwamnatin Netanyahu ba zaman lafiya ba ne sai dai “mamaye Yammacin Kogin Jordan, korar Falasdinawa daga Gaza da sake kafa matsugunan Isra'ila a can.”

Duk da haka, sauyin ba ya takaita ga dalilai na siyasa kawai har da ma matsalolin soja.

Idan aka yi la'akari da yadda wani makami guda na Houthi ya tsallake tsarin kariya na THAAD da Amurka ta samar wa Isra'ila a farkon watan Mayu kuma ya tilasta rufe filin jirgin saman Ben Gurion, wannan ya nuna wani rauni da ba a zata ba a tsarin kariya na makamai da Amurka ta bayar.

Wannan hadarin ya kara ta'azzara da asarar jiragen yaki guda 3 da kuma jiragen sama marasa matuka guda 7.

Wadannan matsalolin tare suna rage muradun Washington a yankin kuma suna iya bayyana dalilin da ya sa kafafen yada labarai ke sake tunani kan matsayinsu game da yakin Isra'ila.

Domin rage barnar, Amurka ta amince da wata “tsagaita wuta tsakanin Washington da hukumomin da suka dace a Sanaa” wanda ya takaita hare-haren Houthi kan jiragen ruwan Amurka yayin da aka bar Isra'ila a gefe.

Tarihi mai maimaita kansa

Tsohuwar wakiliyar CNN ta kasa da kasa kuma mai kafa kungiyar International Network for Aid, Relief and Assistance (INARA), Arwa Damon, tana ganin canjin da ake gani yanzu a yadda kafafen yada labarai na Ƙasashen Yamma ke kallon Isra'ila yana tuna wani yanayi na bayan yakin Iraki na 2003.

“Wannan yana kama da abin da muka gani bayan 9/11 lokacin da kafafen yada labarai na Ƙasashen Yamma da suka bi jirgin yakin gwamnatin Bush suka fara sukar mamayar Iraki da Amurka ta jagoranta, suna tambaya da sukar gwamnatin da labarinta bai dace da abin da kafafen yada labarai ke gani kai tsaye a kasa ba,” in ji ta ga TRT World.

Ta ce irin wannan yanayi ya faru a hankali sosai a Gaza saboda ba a barin 'yan jarida na kasashen waje su shiga, kuma wadanda kawai ke kasancewa a matsayin shaidu kai tsaye su ne 'yan jarida na cikin gida wadanda yawancin editoci ba su yarda da sahihancinsu ba.

“A batun Isra'ila da Gaza, wannan sauyin ya dauki lokaci mai tsawo. Isra'ila ba ta ba da izinin shiga Gaza ga 'yan jarida na kasashen waje saboda wannan dalili, kuma abin takaici 'yan jarida Falasdinawa da suka yi aiki mai ban mamaki har yanzu ana kallonsu ta fuskar tambayar sahihancinsu,” in ji Damon.

Yi somin-taɓin a TRT Global. Bari mu ji ra'ayoyinku!
Contact us